Here’s my thing with musicals. I feel like for a musical to work, you have to have a good singer. Too many times have I seen a movie adaptation of a musical that has its actors sing, and the actors fall flat. I don’t blame the actors at all for this, because who expects someone to be good at acting and also have an academy award winning voice? Lately Hollywood has been autotuning the actors/actresses that are singing (like in the Beauty and the Beast remake), which is ok, but I think I liked it better when actors were just dubbed over by singers (old disney movies do this a lot). Dunno though, a bad dub is just as distracting as having the actors sing.
The best example of this I can think of is Phantom of the Opera… It’s one of those musicals that’s been around forever and has had multitudes of movies made from it. My favorite version of this is the original with Michael Crawford as the phantom. While he’s not the best of actors, the man’s got a good set of pipes. Anyway, in the 2004 remake they replaced him with Gerard Butler, who you may know as Leonidas in 300. Butler’s a great actor, but he’s not the best of singers.
Another example of this is Russell Crowe in Les Misérables. He’s a great actor, but cannot seem to carry much of a tune. I’d argue the same for Anne Hathaway actually, but for some reason I found her performance a bit less distracting. Still, I would have loved it if she was dubbed over. I would have really loved if she were dubbed over by Susan Boyle… I love Boyle’s cover of “I Dreamed A Dream” so much!
Anyway, I’m not really sure what my answer is to this is. Because as I said earlier, bad dubbing can be just as distracting as having the actors sing. Autotuning them helps a little bit, but it can be rather distracting too. Maybe the answer is to get someone who can act and sing, like Idina Menzel?
What do you all think on the matter? Do you like the autotuning? Do you like the actors trying to sing, or do you prefer dubbing? Or do you just think I’m crazy, and that I’m way too easily distracted by the singing in the musicals that have turned into movies?