Ok sure, though I think you’re gonna get voted off without a good explanation. Just trying to help ya hold on a bit longer
I agree that there is no reason to consider EternalMagician a witch at this point, but that’s a rather poor argument since Aspi also apparently did not do anything this night even if King is telling the truth. Unless of course he’s the magic Redirector and the narrative for some reason didn’t say anything about him being the one to use the ability. Which would be weird in its own way, but far from impossible.
Though I will mention that just like last game, Roleblock was suspiciously absent in the writeup, so if it’s a witch ability again like it was the last two times we can say for sure that at least one of the witches did not act, and that might have been Aspi. It’s possible that he simply chose not to use it so as to not be trackable through the narrative. That’s the simplest explanation.
Lol look how that worked out for him
Okay guys ignore all I’ve referred to Eternal as so far, I’ll sort that out of my own accord. There is no reason to suspect him as of now.
Also if pictoshark is a witch and the girl screaming has an explanation then good god would this be the unluckiest round ever. If I were the witches in that situation I’d call gg…
Still Ill bank on my luck while I have it - perhaps Ronove made everyone some Fortune cookies…
There is another possibility of it being a distraction from voting against pictoshark, me and no death. Restkastel possibly lied about visiting @EternalMagician, but she visited another older woman. While @Aspirety actually visited EternalMagician. If we vote no death, then there would be only 1 human dead. Considering that Restkastel and King Titanite were against me and always found me suspicious, King Titanite decided to lie about being detective and say that @Aspirety was a witch. If that’s the truth than Aspirety is older woman and couldn’t be a detective, but this way he pinned the blame on human in order for him to get lynched. So now instead of 1 human, 2 will die.
But maybe I’m reaching way too much, what do you guys think?
Wow @akafa123 that is some good thinking. I would commend you if I didn’t know I was human…but when we lynch Aspy we’ll see if that’s the case or not.
But yeah we do need to take everything into account…of close, everything that doesn’t incriminate me!
Anyway vote switching, everyone? We need 6 to vote out aspy, and I noticed he didn’t vote before signing off. Wow, it’s as if he’s consigned himself to his fate, be him witch or human…
Ok he voted no death earlier, forgot.
Nvm guise
I think that, if @Aspirety was a witch, then the witches were pushing the No Death scenario to avoid killing whichever one of you two was a witch and, if @King_Titanite_XV is a witch, then the witches wanted to do the same thing, and kill off a human (in this case, I don’t think they could have known @Aspirety was detective) and were willing to kill off one of the witches to get that done.
I find the first scenario much more likely than the second, but I think it will all be much clearer when Daylight ends.
Yeah, sure. While I didn’t see any decisive evidence, our situation is favorable enough that I think just voting to kill him is a safe enough bet. The revelation of Aspi’s alignment when he dies will tell us if we’re right or not, and even if it turns out we’re not, we still know one, probably two, witch identities.
Vote: Aspirety
Damn, I really want to trust you, but I just can’t. I don’t know why, it’s like my mind is telling me not to. I don’t even know what to do… I need to hear from others.
Which one of us are you referring to?
King Titanite.
Sorry, I forgot to press quote button.
Not really. It was weird how he left so quickly and didn’t answer fast to obvious questions. I mean, why take a gamble here and lying to us about visiting EternalMagician and being detective? That was really suspicious.
Let’s assume everyone was saying truth until now, :
- Karifean - ???
- Wonderlander - Victim of the crime
- Pictoshark - Murderer that was tracked by me
- Restkastel - Got redirected from Pepe and visited EternalMagician
- Aspirety - Old lady that buttler King Titanite visited, also a Witch.
- PocketyHat - ???
- akafa123 - Crime witness
- King_Titanite_XV - Buttler, detective.
- thesorceress - Could be a young loud lady.
- Pepe - Is probably Rena, because Aspirety and Restkastel told me that her manner of speach suits his introduction
- EternalMagician - Old lady that Restkastel visited, because she got redirected.
- cjlim2007 - ???
So one of these 3 people could be confident woman in the hall. And 2 people did nothing at all?
ALRIGHT! This thread hasn’t met it’s GDA of blues! So let’s get it all up to pace.
**As I know I’m not a witch, I know that akafa is either a witch or a malignant neutral party, therefore from my perspective there is only one catbox sitting before my eyes.
Is @King_Titanite_XV telling the truth?
If he is telling the truth, then Aspirety is a witch. No need to add further reasoning there!
If he is not, then a number of extra catboxes appear before us, as notwitch != human (!= means not equal, by the way).
So if King is lying, what is the nature of that lie? Is Aspirety a neutral who King believes may be a threat to us? In this case, King may be saying Aspi is a witch to simplify the situation for us, as he truly believes Aspirety is harmful to his team.
Or is King a malignant witch, trying to prey on an easy mark of a human? This seems unlikely as it is supremely unlikely for a Witch to choose their mark as the detective, this seem more like a panicked lie from Aspi, after all, his story seems REALLY patched together.
In conclusion the most likely option is Aspi being a witch.
HOWEVER, keep in mind that King is my “blind spot”, he’s my brother so it’s quite hard to feel suspicion towards him.
This fact explains away the only counterargument against King:
We’re brothers, it’s easy to explain this timing of his.
I think I’ll vote for Aspirety too it seems kind of funny to shoot at an admin, and the facts point towards his treachery soooooooooooooo…
Vote: Aspirety[quote=“akafa123, post:296, topic:862”]
And 2 people did nothing at all?
[/quote]
Vanillas, people with one use abilities like mine, the list of justifications carries on till the end of time…
Noooooo my formatting…
AAAAAHHHHHHHHH
HOW DID I NOT SEE THAT???
there is no god.
Rabla wrote in the roles list that vanilla has no roles at all. You told us that you were Vanilla at first, but suddenly you are Crippler, why? I know you was in the same room with Wonderlander, but there is no way to prove it, just like there is no way to prove it that you are not lying about your identity.
Ok guys one more vote, should I push to no vote to get more info or are we ready to move on?