@Restkastel @PocketyHat @Karifean @Antra @EternalMagician @VyseGolbez @Wonderlander @King_Titanite_XV @Doldod @Blue
It’s heartwarming to see all of you bunched up together attempting to solve all the mysteries of this board but we’re already 6 hours in and there haven’t even been any (valid) votes yet.
This upcoming question is at the heart of Mafia, so I expect a good response, alright?
Who do all of you plan to kill this phase?
Since hes being so pushy and wanting to end the phase early its obvious that hes suspicious.
Vote: pictoshark
The game master being involved on the witches end, that sound difficult and chaotic, don’t you think everyone~?
sounds*
Ha ha, I’m almost tempted to vote the same 
But in all seriousness I’m not sure who to vote for actually since we have several people we don’t know anything about (and yes I know that includes me, feel free to ask if you want to know though I’ll probably not be able to answer until I wake up tomorrow).
So right now even though I don’t think it’s a wise move I probably lean towards No Death at the moment. That is unless someone else has any good ideas
If anyone I’d vote someone who hasn’t done much yet just to get them to speak up.
Eh, can’t hurt too much.
Vote: PocketyHat
I am reading all this, I just have no way of contributing since my ability is not an investigative one.
Plus pastebin is blocked in my country. <_<
no, you have no way to contribute because you are incompetent
all jokes aside, i thought picto would give you a really important role to laugh at you. suprised he didnt
Well now, looks like the game master wants to spruce things up a bit since me and King are in a bit of a stalemate right now. Simply put, there’s now an additional way for us to win this little competition. I will win if the Human Team wins with exactly 1 Human Aligned player remaining, and King will win it if the Witch Team wins with exactly 1 Witch Aligned player remaining.
For the purposes of this, King has now been equipped with the knowledge of the Witch Team members and may now communicate with them, while I have to actually try to figure stuff out. Fun times. Give me a sec while I reread the whole topic and actually pay attention to people’s posts this time.
So, basically, Karifean is kinda-sorta a Human aligned player for his own benefit and King is a kinda-sorta Witch for his own benefit? Great. What happens if neither condition is met? Do you just draw the game and be done?
Damn Kari good move. Trouble is he’s lying. We’ve both been equipped with the knowledge of two human players.
I need to kill one and Kari needs to kill another. I’ll just say the person who I’ve been targeted is basically impossible to lynch. Kari has been tasked to lynch Wonderlander (surprise, surprise). They should’ve been given a PM about it, unless Picto lied to us.
I think it tells them that they can freely die and still win the game, provided their team wins. So basically…yeah. If Wonderlander liked Kari enough he could lynch himself to give him game.
This condition fails if No Death is voted. If that occurs a new tiebreaker will come in next discussion phase.
Though there’s nothing saying this idea will be stolen by him!
Lemme post this and ill keep typing later. I don’t want everyone to get tricked.
Can Wonderlander and the second person please check their PMs to confirm this?
So that’s your counter, is it. Well there’s no hurry, it’ll be revealed who’s telling the truth in the long run.
Alright, I exist once more, had an odd fear of forgetting to breathe for some odd reason…
Anyway, back onto this game!~
Hm… there’s really nothing I can really speculate on aside from all the King and Kari shenanigans… For now, I will simply choose to ignore those two, until something says otherwise
What I can say is that I don’t recognize my piece in the phase description. As such, I can’t really prove my position on this gameboard no matter what. And we’ve already speculated on roles and abilities, so there’s nothing much to add from my end, especially since it’s been a while since I’ve played any of these gameboards or had time to pay any attention, So for all intents and purposes, I’m once more a newbie. 
And I can’t really speculate on who we should lynch. I can’t be suspicious of any one of the one’s who revealed their ability already, in case they ARE human aligned, I’m not entirely convinced, but I’m not going to run into that risk. I’m not voting to lynch either of the other aligned ones, because that’s not going to help up in any case.
So then we have the rest of the people who have not claimed anything. No one has come out to claim a piece. From this point, it can go on either like this:
No one claims any piece or reveals what ability they have. Here, the witches have to either kill the useful roles that have been already revealed, or they have to shoot in the dark and kill someone at random, hoping that they were not vanilla. However, for us, humans, we can be stuck in a stalemate of not knowing who is who, so we’re also at a similar position as the witches, we either random lynch, or pick no death. And thus we might have to hope for something to happen in the exploration phase so we can speculate even more afterwards.
Or, it could go like this:
Somebody claims a role or reveals their abilities. This way, we’d either have some hilarious conflict going on between 2 people trying to prove their roles, or we’d have to force witches to do make choices on who to kill, because priority and all that, but at the same time not look too obvious. I also would recommend for Vanillas not to reveal themselves, as this would make it easier for witches to pin down who has any important abilities by process of elimination.
…My thought processing is really dying, so I guess I’m gonna leave that at this. I don’t really have anything else to say, honestly. 
Except my dear Pocketyhat, this is simply incorrect. There is a rather easy way for you to prove your role…at least to me. I have set my empathy on you, so all you must do is PM pictoshark about the details of your power and ask for an explanation about something iconic about it, something for which I can identify it…That is, unless you happen to be a witch hiding behind this excuse about your powers~
In fact, I have verified this is something that I can do with the game master, so I do believe it is in our benefit to check people like this. I can understand if people are suspicious of me, but I do believe I have proven my value to the human side.
What does everyone else think of this plan?
I would disagree, but I was given a red truth saying you’re human.
So go right ahead.
So… Would we check everyone’s roles like that? And how much will you reveal in thread? What if we hit the Protector? I mean witches could get some valuable information out of this too. Unless you keep silent about everyone if they are not an obvious witch. I’m open to the idea but we’d have to rely on you to figure things out.
And if you are a witch we are fucked.
Powers that would be too dangerous to reveal I would keep hidden. Information about suspicious persons I would reveal to everyone, but unless it was necessary I would keep roles to myself. Also I will add that I happen to have a red truth pertaining to the identity of the protector already. I understand if you find me suspicious, but I do assure you that I am human.
I can understand if you are hesitant about leaving the reasoning to me, but I will add that I did take a power that @pictoshark thought would be useless and turn it into our greatest weapon here. He has expressed quite a large amount of disbelief about how many uses for it I have come up with. I ultimately leave this up to you guys, however.
Trouble is Picto will start saying “I refuse” followed by a cackle, won’t he?