So you’d rather not vote at all before going to sleep than voting something?
I mean I probably would have voted Wonderlander so you’re lucky I didn’t
Looking over all the conversation from that night up until now I’ve actually decided I’m pretty confident in Wonderlander’s humanity, so that worked out I suppose.
Which means I’m kind of just back to wondering why King is jumping at every shadow. He’s been kind of hectic just flinging votes in all directions for incredibly minimal reasons.
He probably does it to add pressure. It’s a human move because if he was a witch, then that would not be smart. His reasons are not entirely based and because of it, you have reason to doubt. A witch would normally do that
wouldn’t*
Maybe we could all just vote against the gamemaster considering how the game seems to have fallen pretty much dead.
It’ll pick up pace at the last moments, I’m sure.
I will make a weird drynkish decision to speed things up.
Vote: Rabla
I will support that my making my own vote.
Vote: EternalMagician
Vote: Rabla
Okay, so among the players that didn’t vote for akafa yesterday, for me Rabla, Doldod, and lobotomyprince are most suspicious. Among the players that did vote akafa, if there’s a witch, then it’s either Antra or Muski, but not both.
Especially for lobotomyprince, him conveniently “forgetting” that a flipped witch was actually the first one to unvote back in day 1 and furthermore forgetting that there’s actually no reason to withhold information (or rather his thoughts) is just too suspicious to me.
So for now:
Vote: lobotomyprince
actually I can agree with you vyse.
Kinda a rare thing in these mafia games, but I do see it strange that lobo didn’t understand that doldod didn’t think wonder was a witch. It kinda seems to be like a talk in the witch chat, like “who’s good to jump on? oh, yeah, ill go after doldod, that’ll be good” especially since they backed off so fast.
Vote: lobotomyprince
I dunno, at least over today Lobotomyprince seems like they were just genuinely unsure about what was brought up. I don’t personally think they’re that much of a standout. Though maybe previous days are more suspect; I just personally don’t see what you two are seeing.
On the other hand I’m being put into a situation where I might need to vote for them anyway so they remain the leader on the tally, but I’ll hold off for now.
1 Like
1 Like
If I were a witch, I would hesitate to do something so incriminating as trying to force the vote onto someone else… And I didn’t consider the consequence of playing so aggressively. I was confused by Doldod, and wanted to see if they could explain some things. I don’t consider any of their answers to sway my vote in their direction.
I am a novice… It would be fairly suicidal for a witch to do something so noticable, like pretending not to know the rules. Even if you did believe it, it.would still make me stand out.
I don’t think anyone really had prior concerns about Doldod. It guess if witch me was smarter, I probably would have gone after Rabla or midsummer. Human me would probably also have been smarter…
Gonna just put it out there that I’m not feeling very well (chronic illness) and haven’t for a day or so, so I don’t have much time to think about mafia right now. 
I’ve been a little too aggressive.
I’m not going to vote for myself and dip out. Maybe if it goes to sudden death. Not sure if I’ll be on tomorrow.
Vote:
@Wonderlander
Hope both you and Usagi feel better and can return again soon 
But concerning the game I have started to, once again, think about midsummer as a witch. The reason for this is that we had a pretty clear split between him and Wonderlander and since the Akafa/Wonderlander discussion ended up with Akafa being caught I wonder if it could be the same with midsummer. So I’ll just put this out there until later:
Vote: midsummer
I believe the likeliest group for one witch to be in is the people who voted for Wonderlander. That is, chances are one among SleepingPliskin, Doldod, lobotomyprince and EternalMagician is a witch. If we target them and a witch exists there, even if me might hit a human on the way, we could reach a situation where only one witch is left, which means we’d have a nice amount of time to sniff out the remaining witch. And, looking at how people vote on those four could be illuminating. If we get really lucky, it could even be there’s two witches in that group, though I’m not holding my breath on that turning out to be true.
So, that’s where I will be focusing. Might as well write some impressions on all of them.
-SleepingPliskin: Already wrote some stuff about him. His playstyle is on the edge in that he could be playing a shrewd witch trying to get people around him move in the direction he wants without giving much himself, or he could be a human who’s just trying to get information. It doesn’t help that his only direct influence was in kickstarting the movement against Wonderlander and me. Though it appears that he started that before akafa became a major suspect, which is a point in his favour. If he started throwing suspicion our way only after akafa became a target, that would’ve been somewhat damning.
-Doldod: Still went after Wonderlander today. I can’t say there wasn’t any logic behind that move, but it seems most would agree that the chances of it just wasting our time are too high. He was pretty open about not following through with that strategy if people don’t want to do it, and indeed, he backpedaled on it.
-lobotomyprince: Skimming through her contributions, nothing imediately raised any red flags for me, but Vyse and King make a decent case to suspect her. On day 2, I don’t think she cast suspicion towards anyone else than Wonderlander and me, which I’m still at least half-convinced is a witch-side plot. But it’d be a bit excessive to assume everyone involved in that is a witch. Also, just noticed she’s still gunning for Wonderlander.
-EternalMagician: Has been pretty inactive, as usual. He managed to completely go under my radar on day one by being more active than usual, but after that, he quickly faded away into the shadows. Which makes for a good witch side strategy. Suspicion based on inactivity is usually thrown around on day one - survive that, and then people will have enough legitimate reads that inactivity can easily go unnoticed. And being inactive certainly doesn’t help the human side at all. If there’s an active witch and a less active witch left, EternalMagician is a solid witch pick.
Also, something I’d like to point out is that with the exception of Doldod, it seems like it is this group and this group alone that pushes forward the idea that I am a witch. In addition to their efforts on day 2, SleepingPliskin mentioned just a while ago that I’m his prime suspect, lobotomyprince just lamented that he should’ve gone for me (or Rabla) instead, and EternalMagician just directly went and voted me. This group pretty likely includes at least one witch. Make out of that what you will.
Regarding EternalMagician’s vote… there was a clear split between me and Wonderlander? What exactly do you mean? I was under the impression that both of us were targeted because of activity, whereas akafa was targeted because he was acting unusually compared to how he was in previous games in which he was a human. How, exactly, is the difference between me and Wonderlander comparable to the difference between Wonderlander and akafa? And even if there was a difference, how would it follow that because akafa was a witch, other suspects beside Wonderlander are also likely to be witches?
Regarding who to vote… it’s a tough decision since pretty much all of the above four people seem like good choices to me. I guess Pliskin isn’t really my prime suspect anymore. EternalMagician’s last post really caught my attention, so I suppose I’m gunning for him for now. That, and his analysis post on day one just reinforces the idea that he could give useful analysis, but chooses not to.
Vote: EternalMagician
If you can clarify your reasons for voting for me, I might change my mind. Because for now, I really don’t understand where that argument came from.