Garry’s Mod, 100% Orange Juice and Civilization V all come to mind for me. I’m not very good at real time strategy or 2D fighters, but I can play most other genres~
Another idea is The Ship. Admittedly I’ve never played it myself, but I’ve heard good things and it seems like a very fitting game for our cohort here. A competitive murder mystery game. I’d love to try it out with you guys.