Sorry guys, a bit late to the party. And ouch @pictoshark, seemingly less useful newbie? While that is probably true it still hurt
Okay first of all, dear @thesorceress , can you state your exact win conditions? Just staying alive with both pinks? Can you clear your conditions?
As for my role, I think I should reveal it:
I am unfortunately also Vanilla like @Aspirety here. Me being the young girl means @Pepe is the servant with the role. I wonder what his role is. @Pepe, any input so far?
As for the whole @EternalMagician and @pictoshark debacle, while you guys are right and they can be both human. It is entirely possible that they both are witches. Or at least, that @EternalMagician is. It is extremely suspicious that the person that was targeted was completely unrelated to the switcher debacle as @PocketyHat pointed out. He doesn’t have to fake his being Hideyoshi, just his alignment. The killer was an older man as well.
But while the above outcome IS quite possible, compared to the other outcome that he is telling the truth, it is very unlikely. We do know that @pictoshark was visited by an older man who asked him questions. If anybody else has the Detective role, we do know that there is a protector, so the detective could reveal themselves without any setbacks I suppose. But that is a risk the detective will have to take.
It doesn’t sound like we have a roleblocker this time around, so we have to figure out what is the other witch role. But maybe they could have been silent as to not draw attention. I just find it very odd that @pictoshark decided to switch somebody on the first day, even though he said the people he switched AND he revealed his role.
I find it odd that @SuperM has still been silent. I wonder what is up with that.
As for @Karifean, I think he is innocent, simply because he didn’t have to share his deductions with us. Yet he did. Any suspicions on anyone @Karifean? You are a smart guy. We could use your help.
@Necem? I do love your deductions as well, any input? Yours too @Aspirety. And @RegNewmont? What do you have to think?