No not literally-
Never mind.
The thing that Iāve been stuck upon is that if @akafa123 is a witch then announcing that they witnessed the murder and pointing out a suspect is amongst the worst decisions they could make. While thereās a possibility that you might were mislead through some ability the odds of you managing to track the, supposed, murderer and you being hit with that ability in the same turn is really small. So while it might be the case that you were mislead through some (passive?) ability or that you really are a witch I feel that the chance of that is much smaller than the chance of you actually being correct.
That and the fact that thereās just something bugging me about how @pictoshark and @King_Titanite_XV are covering for each other. While it is very much possible that you really are staying in the same house for Christmas it could also be a tactic amongst the witches for aiming us humans towards a target, especially since the one they are pointing towards right now is one of the few with a confirmed ability.
So Iāll actually go against most people here and put in: Vote:pictoshark
Ok checked and it the deadline is 13 hours not 1. Am and Pm times mustāve fuck ed with Asperity a bit
I can actually confirm as an outside party that itās true. Heās mentioned it before semi-vaguely but theyāre actually brothers. Iāve talked to them both before when they were at the same house and switching between each other on mic.
Also you seem to be assuming competence when there very well might not be competence. Assuming that we would take him at his word because of what he said before, he announced that he saw the murder to be used as a sacrificial pawn to get rid of pictoshark who happens to be a nuisance to people on gameboards despite the fact his memory is terrible.
ā¦ Well there goes that theoryā¦ and you might be right about that, but Iām still not sure about lynching @akafa123 so Iāll change to Vote: No Vote instead until what I feel is more concrete proof have been provided.
Well he got killed last time early for some reason (I forget why), probably just because he sticks out.
But yeah Eternal donāt worry Iām fine with no voting since that way we can get a large opinion.
You see me as suspicious because I was the first to vote on someone. After the death announcement I said that pictoshark is the killer. And I might be the witch with tracker ability who could track the murderer from the witch team itself and blame it on human.
But you see, wouldnāt it be easier for me to suspect someone, who hasnāt revealed their piece or role? Like for example Aspiriety? He didnāt say if he was a witch or human nor his role. If I told that it was him, there would be less suspicion. But pictoshark revealed his piece beforehand and thatās why you get confused. He says that he couldnāt lie because of his playstyle, but thatās not very strong reason.
If I blamed someone without a role that would be less suspicious, but I blamed someone who I tracked last night, someone who I witnessed in the same room with Wonderlander. It was pure luck, but I saw it with my own eyes.
Very funny that you say thatā¦
ā¦actually nevermind. Iāll bring that up at twilight. Someone remind me if twilight fully passes and I didnāt say something
That doesnāt really change much. As I was saying, the witch team would want to kill Picto specifically early, like what happened before I believe, which is why you decided to declare him as the witch. Anyway, as we all said before, if you are telling the truth we just know who to lynch tomorrow.
Man this topic is active.
Iām not as convinced @akafa123 is the guilty party in this conflict as the rest of you seem to be. Maybe itās because I know firsthand what itās like to place all your cards face-up on the table in the hopes of getting your fellow allies to believe you, and then having everyone still think youāre up to something Xx Though they are a bit more defensive about it than I think one would be in that scenario, so I canāt say Iām convinced theyāre innocent eitherā¦
Whatās also troubling is that if we do make a wrong move, we lose either a Tracker or Crippler, both of which are quite useful.
How about this: we vote No Death this round. During nighttime phase the people with checking abilities check the alignments/roles of akafa123 and pictoshark, which hopefully is enough to come to a conclusion on who is really guilty here. Then we execute them next daylight phase. The problem with this strategy is of course that it gives the witches a certain free kill this night, but if the alternative is to risk losing a Tracker or Crippler AND give the witches another free kill tonight, it might be better?
Thatās my thoughts, though before I vote No Death Iād be glad if someone else looked over it again and pointed out if I missed something that would make this strategy not work as well as I hope.
I suppose that could work, something tells me something unfortunate will happen but since Im not one to just go on gut about something like this here is what I propose.
The protector protects Titanite as I have a feeling on who they might be.
I follow picto
Someone else with a tracking ability follows Akafa123
If we can agree to this then I would be up to this plan.
Thatās exactly what I did. I revealed everything I could, including my role, name and ability to help investigation. I believe there wasnāt contradiction in anything I said with narrative. Out of all people the only ones without claimed personalities are:
Karifean
Aspiriety
Pocketyhat
King Titanite
Pepe (according to his introduction, he seems like Rika)
and cjlim2007
We rule out 2 other girls from narrative that we know identities of - Restkastel, Pepe. Also there was a loud young lady, which might be one of the 6, but she was in the room with another woman, so she couldnāt witness the crime. So one of those 7 people witnessed the murder, I was the one who claimed the role of a girl beforehand and the one who claimed to be that mysterious girl behind the door, which I agree, might seem suspicious. But did anyone else claim that he saw the murder? Did anyone else claimed to be a girl behind that door? Did anyone else claimed to have a role of tracker? No one didā¦ And because of that I canāt prove myself, because people arenāt willing to reveal their pieces, because they think Iām a witch now, trying to frame someone else. And this whole thing is a big opportunity to witches to confuse all humans and to kill tracker - me.
Itās risky, but the alternative is probably even more risky. Maybe we guess right and hunt the witch, maybe we guess wrong and lose two humans. when you put it that way, it may be safer to hold back for one more night until we hare some certainty.
Vote: no death
At least now nobody can rock majority.
Have*
Hold on, why do we rule out Rena? Shes suspicious as hell because I got -misdirected- away from her. We donāt have enough information on her to act either way but that really, really was suspicious to me in the first place. If you hadnāt gone and seemingly lied I would have been arguing we should be more suspicious of Pepe.
Should I have worded that Change vote: no death instead?
Iām still happy to lynch Akafa if thatās what the group decides, but I just wanted to protect the vote from being decided prematurely by majority. And the more I think of it, the more Iām coming to like the idea of watching and waiting. If one of them is a witch, they are already in check, if not checkmate.
Regarding Rena, she certainly does seem to fit the narrative description of the killer. Iād have been sold if the weapon was a hatchet 
1 Like
@Pepe is Rena and you got misdirected from her? So that means that she could be that mysterious girl too, thatās what you are saying?
I would agree to change my vote to no vote if Restkastel and King Titanite agree to do so.