Either that or the killer.
Damn, I guess there are really no way to prove that Iām tracker, because I really saw him in the same room with Wonderlander.
How did you know he was Rena by the way, did he revealed it?
OKAY. I wake up and some nonesense is happening.
Iām not sure what to do right now but just reading the end of this threadā¦I donāt think voting No Death is a good idea. We just give the witches a chance to kill again tonight and the detective hasnāt revealed himself yet so we donāt know who to trust and weāll end up going through another daylight full of doubt which would get us no where.
On one hand, everything @akafa123 is saying is incredibly shady. Their story does not line up with what has been previously established and their explanations donāt really make any sense. On the other hand, to me that implies that thereās been some way that they have been tricked, because I cannot imagine that any witch team would decide to frame someone as the murderer who doesnāt line up with the information provided. This means that either 1. the witch team made a horrible mistake that has spiraled out of their hands 2. @pictoshark is lying about his role and @akafa123 is just not explaining themselves very well or 3. somehow or another @akafa123 has been mislead about the information presented from tracking @pictoshark.
Option 1 means that @akafa123 is a witch, option 2 means that @pictoshark is a witch, and option 3 means that they are both human and we are officially in the worst position we could be.
I am dismissing option 3 for now for my own emotional stability. If we end up lynching a human, then I will return to it.
Regarding option 1: @akafa123, I think, has to be the tracker because the description at the end says mysterious young girl, which is exactly how Alice was described last game. And it really doesnāt make any sense for a witch to have tracked the murderer. There is no real way that @akafa123 could have known that there wouldnāt be an Alice in this game or a tracker. This seems like a ridiculous amount of things to lie about in order for us to get @pictoshark lynched, especially if they were lying, they would immediately be lynched. This would require a ridiculous amount of risk taking on the part of the witches to come up with a plan which had a major horrible hole in it from the beginning
Regarding option 2: @pictoshark is right, the description that was given of the murder does not fit with the information given at the description. However, I am more willing to believe that you lied about your role, or conspired with another member of your team to switch roles (as in, each of the witches would claim to be another member of the group to take suspicion away from the murderer). That was my original theory. But everything that has been so confusing that Iām not certain what to think anymore.
And all of this is discounting the idea that we are being majorly mislead and someone made @akafa123 think something that wasnāt true was true.
Vote: pictoshark
I am willing to be talked out of that though.
Also @Restkastel I agree @Pepe is shady and, if we get the witch this round, the detective should probably look into them.
His induction post was obviously immitating Renaās manner of speech. It is incredibly distinct.
Oh, really? I read only first chapter of Higurashi and I heard Bern doing Nipaah in Umineko, so I thought it was Rika, heh.
He didnāt say Nipahā¦
Oh, he said Hau, well idk, I didnāt read Higurashi that much, so excuse me.
This whole day I was thinking about what If I saw was a lie? But It had to be 100% pictoshark as a killer. Because when I followed pictoshark he was the one in the room with wonderlander. This, ofcourse, if you trust me of being human tracker. The only way for this to be wrong is someone took an identity of pictoshark at night to kill wonderlander, but is there a role for that?
p.s: excuse me for my english. itās my second language, so i might make mistakes in grammar sometimes.
Iād be down for this plan if the detective, who it seems like we have, investigated either @pictoshark or @akafa123. This is only because I still think itās possible that there was some sort of trick last night and that they could both be human. If I was certain as yesturday that one was a witch, I donāt think I would go for this.
What were you going to say here? Thereās no time like the present.
I agree. I shall be changing my vote as well to no death.
Change vote: No Death
Sorceress, since I am fairly sure that you have the loud voice and double vote we do need to ensure that you are voting with the rest of us. If we get the detective to investigate someone to determine their alignment, we should investigate @pictoshark. That was if we find out that he is who he says he is we can be fairly sure that @akafa123 is either lying or incompetent. I myself will be trying to follow Rena again because I find her suspicious.
Is @King_Titanite_XV here? Will he agree to change his vote?
Is it absolutely necessary to use the detective on picto though? Iād think using the investigator in him would yield enough info by determining whether or not he was lying about his character, and using the detective on akafa would eliminate any uncertainty left.
Also helps to split it up like that in case one of them gets roleblocked. Using detective on picto would be a waste.
That sounds like a good idea. If @akafa123 is human then weāll know most likely that pico is a witch and if theyāre a witch we wonāt have problems.
@Aspirety, if you change your vote, Iāll change mine. Both to no death?
Okay guys fine Iāll reveal this. Didnāt want to yet buuut
I am detective this round. I have taken the role of Ronove, the greatest tea creator of all time. Hereās the kicker though: I investigated Asperity and found he was on the witch team.
To be honest Iād be more willing to believe I was cheated out of a correct result by an ability as Asperity has been acting fairly nice so far and being quite civil. I need everyone elseās thoughts on this as this is one hell of a clusterfuckā¦
I already changed my vote~
Why did the color thing not work guise? Ahhhh
So yeah you guys can see why it took me so long to think about this. Asperity makes a good point but Iāve been told he is an enemy. So what do I do?
Wait wait wait what? Seriously?
Okay! To everybody else, if you are the detective please say so now. If @King_Titanite_XV is lying we need to know as soon as we can.
To @Aspirety, please reveal your character and role at this time. Itās necessary.
If this turns out to be true, I think we need to lynch @Aspirety. Itāll be more productive than a No Desth vote.