It does matter. The mysterious girl described in the narrative was almost certainly @akafa123. Who seems to have followed @Pepe with @Restkastel, if I’m piecing together the narrative of last night correctly. There is no indication that the mysterious girl and the small girl are the same person at all and there’s all indications that they are different people. Alice is the tracker and doesn’t seem to have been around the last deaths at all.
It’s not hard to lie about your role when you can fake the role of another witch. I think @pictoshark is it.
Did you find out any info other than the character about @Pepe? This is directed toward @akafa123 or @Restkastel.