@akafa123 is not the killer, they may be a witch but they are not the killer since they seem able to follow and nobody disputes this
@PocketyHat @pictoshark and @Karifean are the only three that should be under doubt right now likely for being the actual murderer.
Why are we assuming akafa can follow people if they are a witch they can get someone else to do that for them. The witches can private chat, yāknow.
Taking last round into account, I think itās most likely @pictoshark. But I want to hear from @akafa123 before doing anything.
Because someone else out of that list would have to be the tracker instead and would have to -actually- have that role. We do know that it is not rena though since the killing -was not observed-
Im pretty sure about this at least, my gut instincts are telling me these are the likely three, with akafa maybe being a fourth but then there would have to move at least one of the witches on to the alibi track
WE KNOW the amount of alibis and have a good idea of who they are at least.
The only way that I can think for @akafa123 to be the killer is for them to have lied about being Alice and the tracker to begin with, because I think itās a reasonable assumption that Alice is the mysterious young girl mentioned in the narration and the abilities said young girl shows are only really consistent with a tracker.
Which means that someone on the witch side is Alice and a tracker, and that they allowed akafa123 to take the identity of Alice and the tracker and lie about being it, in order to frame @pictoshark for the murder on the second daylight, a plot that would have immediately been revealed if not for you investigating and finding out that Aspirety were a witch. Which would mean that the tracker was another witch, which is a role that a witch would not find much use for, and followed @Pepe, a person whom they know the alignment of, in order to give @akafa123 a chance to kill someone tonight. I do not find this series of events in any way likely.
Unless the narrative is misleading us in some way and the mysterious young girl is the same as the killer, which the narrative seems to be saying is not true, I am inclinded to believe that @akafa123 was telling the truth and @pictoshark is the killer.
Well at least I know youāre not a witch so I can take your words at fave valueā¦
We need to be careful now since one wrong vote and we can lose the game if all the witches are ready to post their votes together.
This is pretty much the truth here. If I wanted to update the alibis to include this I will say this.
@Restkastel
@King_Titanite_XV
@thesorceress
@Pepe
The Lifesaver
The Mysterious Girl
The Redirector
Possible Without Alibi:
@pictoshark
@PocketyHat
@Karifean
@akafa123
And with that we come to something of a realization. Pictoshark is lying for sure. There are not enough non-murderer roles for him to have not acted last night.
Lemme do the math, on my adding I was 1 out but you look to be right
I donāt see your math?
To me it looks like thereās exactly enough for me to fit?
There are 8 players remaining.
Arenāt they the killer?
No they were in the room with me visiting Rena.
Iām waiting for @Karifean to speak up.
Also, another thing to note, if we do lynch the killer somehow, weāll have to figure out who the rest of the witches are. Iām sure that they wonāt be able to kill anyone else. Theyāll have to be smart and lynch people one by one. Which is pretty hard to do, honestly, as an experience from being a former witch.
Although I do still think that picto is the killerā¦ If not, well, -shrug- but again, Iām gonna wait for @akafa123 to speak up.
Butā¦ is it really that simple thoughā¦? This would imply that there were originally 3 witches all along. Come on, I thought this would be harder than it should be. I really feel like weāre missing something.
This means that Pictoshark is one of three roles for sure.
Killer, Protector, or Redirector.
The beginning of the write up is a bit confusing. I think I have to be the tough young visitor that @King_Titanite_XV was visiting but would the gloomy young girl be the one he was redirected from? Meaning @pictoshark?
He got the redirector thing wrong so he isnāt one of them. I saw his get confused so I would know.
So itās killer or protector? Iād go with the former but wait for akafa first.
Theres no way for me to be missing something here. Myself, Pepe, and The Mysterious Girl all have an alibi from the narration.
The detective and the lifesaver were together and visited Mion who they learned was a neutral.
This leaves four. @Karifean @pictoshark @PocketyHat and @akafa123 though I am inclined to believe Akafa is the mysterious girl who was with me and is telling the truth about Picto now.
Thatās what Iām saying. The write up states that you talked with a ātough young girlā after passing a gloomy young girl muttering about suspicion. Who, if Iām not mistaken, is who you were redirected away from not the redirector. Unless Iāve misunderstood the narration completely. Which is possible. What do you guys think?