Rokkenjima Mafia - Game III [Game Over - Human Side Victory]

Gameboards
#121

Rena would fit with the limited description of what we have on the murderer and you were directed to someone who seems to be vanilla. It would be a pretty lucky break for a witch to find and redirect you immediately but it’s certainly not unlikely.

I very much want to hear from @pictoshark as well. On one hand, the character that he claims to have doesn’t sound much like the murderer, though I’ve never played so don’t know much about him, and I doubt pictoshark would lie about his character. On the other hand, for @akafa123 to be lying about what’s going on here seems like a ridiculously risky move and I find it unlikely that the tracker is a witch.

I feel like I’m missing something. If Alice is a human aligned tracker, that makes it sound like she’s not on a third and separate team. Which makes me think that there’s been another twist thrown in this game that I don’t know about.

@akafa123, can you tell me, do you have a teammate? What are your win conditions?

#122

I didn’t get any win conditions. The only thing @Rabla said was that my goal is to escape boredom. I guess I’m human just like everyone else, because there weren’t any specific win conditions.
And it wasn’t stated if I have teammate or not, so I guess I’m just a human.

#123

…Where is @pictoshark?
Seriously, the poor fool is a blabberer, he even talked in the night phase.

Hm… is there a possibility that there’s a Silencer in this game this time around? I mean, there’s nothing in the writeup that implies that but… food for thought.

Personally, I don’t think anyone was silenced, but the fact that @pictoshark isn’t talking is concerning. That, or he’s really a witch.
Also, if @akafa123 was a witch, why would they even risk revealing their role? Unless the number of witches this time around is huge, so some of them might be expendable.
Also, let’s think of it this way, if we lynch Picto, we’re either possibly losing a vanilla player, or killing a witch. But if we lynch akafa, we’re losing a Tracker, or killing a witch. Unless Picto lied about him being vanilla and he’s trying to not make himself much of a target for the witches.

Mh… I’m honestly not sure what to believe, but I really want to hear from everyone.

#124

Okay. Last game, there was a third team with separate win coniditions from the rest of the group, that being Usagi and Alice were supposed to both stay alive the whole game and it didn’t matter if the witches or humans won. It doesn’t sound like Alice is a part of that this time and is just a normal member of the island.

If there is a third team, they’re probably nothing to worry about because they’re probably human, and, if not, then they can be treated like any other witch. But there might not be a third team this game so there’s probably nothing to worry about on that front.

#125

I see! If there was Usagi in that game, I would have knew, but seems like she is not present. Atleast he entertained me with the fragment he presented.

#126

Quite, the fact that @pictoshark isn’t talking seems rather suspicious. The fact we have a possible silence and a suspicious accusation make me want to wait until later or more discussion before we rush ourselves. We have a great deal of time as long as we do not force ourselves into voting to figure things out.

I want to hear his defense before we lynch him, that much is for sure.

1 Like
#127

Rabla did present this game as the “most difficult one yet” and we also have the highest number of players of any game so far, so I highly doubt this game is as simple as having a small number of witches and no third team. The guy’s probably cooked up something pretty frightening. It’s for this reason that I definitely still want to hear from pictoshark as well.

Your team comes in form of your alignment btw so “Human Aligned” is what tells you you’re not on a third team.

1 Like
#128

It’s strange. I feel like something must have happened last night that we’re missing. I’m doing a new write up based on new information. Basically going to recap what we know, but in a different format.

Assuming no one is lying, last night:

  1. @Restkastel as Maria tracked 2. @Pepe as arena but was redirected (3. assuming that the redirector was not someone mentioned elsewhere) toward 4. @EternalMagician who did nothing.

Then 5. a confident woman protected me 6. @thesorceress as Mion (I am assuming that this was me because the person was described as loud)

Then 7. the butler detective (confident so Gohda?) invesigated an old woman 8. who the narration said did nothing last night but is not elaborated on further.

Then our poor dead 9. Wonderlander Rose was killed by 10. mysterious individual (@pictoshark?) who was tracked by 11. Alice @akafa123.

Which leaves all unknown roles for @Karifean, @King_Titanite_XV, @PocketyHat, @Aspirety, and @cjlim2007 as the detective, the confident woman, the redirector???, the old woman investigated, and the inactive one, in any order.

This is operating under the assumption that no people were more than one of these people last night (the redirector could easily be anyone else for example) and that leaves only one person who did not act of get tracked last night.

Assuming there have been no lies or misunderstandings here, which is a big assumption, then seven of the roles last night are clear. The only one I find clearly in doubt is that @pictoshark is really the killer. If we believe @Restkastel, which I do for not, neither she nor @EternalMagician did anything last night. The detective knows the old lady’s role but she didn’t do anything (I’m assuming she’s human because if she was a witch I’m going to guess the detective would have revealed that information. A confident woman protected me which I am greatfull for.

Everything about the information from last night points to the idea that there aren’t many witches which, like @Karifean said, doesn’t really seem possible. I don’t think any of the information above is inaccurate, but I do think that we’re missing something seriously important about the roles this time and that’s going to be a problem for the rest of the game.

1 Like
#129

Please let me know if I missed something or got something incorrect. I’m trying to compile all the information we have to get the best grasp of the situation, so if anyone believes that they were in the write up last night or thinks I’ve forgotten something, I’d like to know. I don’t think any of us want to take any action before hearing from @pictoshark, but I find this whole situation so shady that, if anyone has reason to disbelieve anything that I’m assuming happened last night, I would really like to hear it.

Also @Pepe was supposed to be Rena. Autocorrect is evil.

1 Like
#130

@Pictoshark should be posting shortly - he is currently hurt by something completely unrelated to daggers through backs

#131

Also I know the witches know who the witches and non watches are, but do they know our characters, roles or anything else from the get-go or do they have to work everything out like us?

#132

?

What do you mean by the @pictoshark thing? Being hurt I mean.

From what I understand witches know what everyone else does, except for who the other witches are. They have to figure everything out like the rest of us do.

#133

We’re brothers in the same house for Christmas. I REEEEALLY badly injured myself, it’s why I haven’t been posting today.

Present! At last!

I am not a murderer, instead, akafa123 is on a team with the killer who they intentionally observed tonight. Then, they accused me using a false accusation, as I branded myself vanilla, and am an easy target.

Alternatively, akafa is on a neutral team with the killer, who must get a certain number of kills by the end of the game or something similar.

My theory is not devoid of evidence! After all, The basic propoerties of various characters is mentioned in the narrative, the killer had no characteristics mentioned, except for their girly laugh.

Therefore, the killer is female, this does not clear me of suspicion, as I could have lied about my role, but that doesn’t fit my playstyle.

I would post here that my meat doll is male, but I’ll probably be nuked for that, so I’ll just say it in bold.

My piece is male.

You are Leo Shishigami, Human Aligned Cool Guy

I want to emphasize something: A basic property of each of the acting characters has always been mentioned in the narrative up to this point. Again, this is a constant, it always happens. If it weren’t for this track, how would we know the killers identity? The laugh was that characteristic.

I think we should lynch @akafa123, or we will fall into the witch’s trap. There’s too many inconsistencies with their story.

I know my story is out there, but it matches the facts

#Which you can’t say about akafa’s

1 Like
#134

Pepe, you baka! I already covered that with number 2!

#135

I’ll let him explain the top one if he wants.

Also thanks. That makes my next moves clear.

#136

I do think that this is a good idea, after all, it does make sense with everything he has said. I do however want to wait as long as possible to hear from cjim since he has yet to speak whatsoever which is very suspicious to me.

Furthermore, I do still hold suspicion about pepe considering the fact that I was redirected from following him. This may or may not have been intentional, but I do think it is very suspicious indeed, at least until further evidence clears things up.

#137

Yeah, I’m asking how you know that.

#138

Muh post, read muh post. Brothers. Under same roof.

#139

RAH Read his post
"We live in the same house for Christmas"
There you go, thats how I know.

Anyway I’m going to wait till morning. If I haven’t heard anything then I’m going to doubt @akafa123 and lynch them.
Good luck you lot!

#140

In case there were any doubts as to how British King is, we doubt no more.