I see, I admit I am new to this so I am unsure of what exactly the perils on the island are. However in any case, I do believe we should hear from everyone this time around, not just those who have already posted. I believe those we haven’t heard from are @pictoshark @PocketyHat @Aspirety and @cjlim2007
I will also point out that cjim has not talked at all or casted a vote that we know of
I just noticed that as I was posting Pockety, I was posting that as you were it seems. As for my own theory on alice, I cannot be sure if it is the truth or not. We have so little information to go on.
If no one else claims to be the little girl at the end who saw the murder, I say that we assume that that is Alice. Of course, there’s nothing saying that Alice isn’t a witch and I honestly have no idea how said mysterious young girl would have seen the murder. As Alice last time, I had no nighttime abilities, but I was also other world aligned so I have no idea how that role might have been changed.
Anyway, I feel inclinded to believe the mysterious girl is @akafa123, but not certain I can tell if they’re a human or a witch and I’m not certain I understood their claims about the culprit correctly or believe them if I do.
I don’t really know what to make of them. So far at least nobody has claimed to be the actual mysterious girl (and we can deal with that possibility if it happens) so there’s no reason to doubt that’s who she is. Which leaves us with the classic problem of “if she’s human, she’s telling the truth, if she’s a witch, she’s lying.” The upside to that problem of course is that - discounting the possibility of them being third-party aligned with an ulterior motive - if we can determine whether or not she’s telling the truth, we know the identity of one witch for sure. So it’s a question of whether we act on her claim straight away or wait until we can confirm it with the help of the detective and/or other checking abilities.
(I’m just going to assume @akafa123 is accusing pictoshark at this point, they haven’t confirmed it but the implications in their post point to no one else)
Out of curiosity, were you informed of the fact that you were protected or did you just assume it? I don’t remember that being a thing last game.
I’m just assuming it because the person was described as loud. I could be wrong, but I don’t think I am.
Wow, you sure are talkative, so much discussion while I was away.
Let me settle this boring discussion and get straight into action!
I officially confirm that my role is Tracker!
Last night I witnessed a horrible murder which, without a doubt, was made by @pictoshark!
Was it a pure luck or my incredible intuition, but I decided to observe him last night and oh my, that was very cruel, stubbing someone on the back. What a boring murder! Anyway, I’m on human side for sure and I can even say that I’m sacrificing myself right now, so we can kill the witch! Because next daylight, I might not be alive…
Therefore, I announce my vote!
Vote: pictoshark
We didn’t know Rose that much, but we should bring justice to her name!
Between what I have said and what was said in the writeup you can probably figure it out. I can confirm I’m not a tracker though. Hes not lying and saying hes the tracker.
Thank you!
Im going to say this now, I think theres a few suspicious things about this considering Pictoshark introduced himself as a male, and the killer seems to be a young girl as far as we can tell. This, to me, provides a bit of a conflict to me. Perhaps we ought to investigate this before we jump to any conclusions, but this might just be me being a bit overly suspicious. Who knows. He did leave out a very important possibility with the vote conflict however, which makes me a bit suspicious especially considering that now in the writeup that Loud lady could easily have been the loudmouth who had to vote twice.
I get the feeling that likely Sorceress’s role is that of the loudmouth but thats just a bit of speculation on my paty.
As @PocketyHat pointed out, the killer was stated to have a girlish laugh but was never referred to with pronouns or even given a description. So I’m not going to get hung up with gender right now, even though it does seem more likely the killer was a girl, the narration could be messing with us.
I’m inclinded think, at this point, that either @pictoshark or @akafa123 is a witch. If we vote right this round, we take out a witch. If we vote wrong this round, we’ll know who to go after next daylight at least. Since Alice is stated to be human aligned this game, I’m assigning her win conditions are different too.
Also I’m not a loudmouth…I just have a strong voice.
Someone please confirm that @Pictoshark is of a real character from Rose Gun Days as I know he has not read the work and am inclined to believe him on who he is as a result. A “cool guy” shouldn’t have a girlish voice.
If someone let’s me know that I’m right then my view is entirely changed - I’ll be targeting @akafa123 if that occurs, due to a blatant lie.
Make your cases known if you don’t agree with me, everyone! Also I hope this doesn’t break any rules…
I think we should hear from him and his defense as a result. That much is for sure, I will not be voting until we get a good answer out of the accused. I do agree that one or the other is definitely suspicious, though which one it is has yet to be seen unless we can verify some information, that much is definitely for sure.
I will also mention that the fact that I got redirected away from Rena makes me rather suspicious, so we should take that into consideration as well.
Goddamnit y’all need to go read Rose Guns Days. Yes, Leo Shishigami is a real character from Rose Guns Days, and he is an incredibly over the top awesome guy.
Though that’s information a simple VNDB lookup will give you so trusting him based on just that is not the best idea.
Can someone tell me how do you colorcode your text? Is it available to everyone or not?
It’s in our code of conduct. But here:
[color=blue]Blue text[/color]
shows up as
Blue text
Oh, I see. Thank you.