Rokkenjima Mafia - Game IV [Game Over - Human Side Victory]

That’s honestly a difficult question. The people high up on my list of suspicious right now are Lucia, Higanbana, Mion and Kanon, and most of these are really only on there because they either haven’t said much or haven’t said much significant. I also almost feel you shouldn’t try to hit Lucia again and shouldn’t actually say who you are going to shoot, to take care of the two cases that Lucia lied about being bulletproof and a Protector existing on the witch side.

I don’t really take today’s votes into account as I feel the amount on incriminating testimonies was enough for the witches to decide that it’s strategically advantageous to just let Alice die and not color themselves suspicious in trying to defend her.

I agree with Gabe on pretty much everythin’ hes said. 'Specially the part about not trying to shoot the little ravenette again. Don’t say who you’re going to shoot, but keep that in mind. We just gotta use our heads and we can figure out who the other culprits are. So long as we stay smart 'bout it all we can figure this all out.

Alternatively, someone could have Protected me. Remember that part?

That still seems kinda fishy but whatever. I suppose if we take you at you’re word that’s true. Thats just me though.

Let’s be level. Odds are the Witches are gonna kill me tonight. I mean, SURELY they will, right? I think a protect on me wouldn’t be a protect wasted. That’s just my opinion though.

Why didn’t you count @MAFIA_Black_Battler in your list of people suspicious due to inactivity? Surely I’ve posted more than him.
Tee, hee.

Anyways, Leo, you have every right to be suspicious, since his story is bizarre- but this whole game is hardly the norm. Gabriel said he too received a Flash of Inspiration? I get the feeling it isn’t anything sinister, especially since it didn’t work the second time round. Of course, this is basically my gut instincts, and knowing what it was can’t possibly hurt.

I think deciding who Kinzo should kill is important for us to discuss if he does happen to survive the night- if we just skirt around the topic or tell him not to kill anyone, surely he wouldn’t listen. (And surely he won’t wind up dead, either…)

Out of these, the only one I’ve been personally eyeing is Kanon, who seems to be actively avoiding needing to participate unless called out. He did come out of the shadows to vote for Alice, but it’s quite a common strategy to help kill a fellow Witch who is gone for sure…

1 Like

I apologize for not speaking very much, my ability doesn’t tell me very much, so what I know I can trust is quite limited…
I am a bit curious since Alice was doomed to die, it could be very possible those who discovered her were doing it on purpose… I don’t know if we can make anything decisive without more information, sadly.

I guess it’s possible that Gabriel could be a Witch and this is part two of the mastermind strategy to vouch for Kinzo as the Human Team Killer and he’ll just happen to keep being protected but accidentally keep hitting Humans, but the bigger the Anti-Kinzo theory gets the more ridiculous it seems.

I think @MAFIA_Gabriel can be trusted, so I’d like to hear some more reasoning for who he thinks we should be wary of at this point.

1 Like

I mean, I suppose that could be true. But how would ya explain the fact that I saw him visit Alice last night? I mean, in that case wouldn’t I need to be in cahoots with him or he would have had to know that I was gunna track him?

Wow I was away for a while and not only did we catch a witch the vote was also cut short, seems like the last few days has been full of surprises.

As for this flash of inspiration some of you have reported I have no idea. If what @MAFIA_Gabriel and @MAFIA_Kinzo says is true then it wouldn’t seem to be a redirect or something but it feels like it either is a side effect of an ability or an entirely new one to this game. Not sure which.

Funnily enough, that post just put you on the same level as Black Battler, before that you had posted one post less. But in your case, it wasn’t the number itself, but what you said. You were the main candidate I was referring to when I said [quote=“MAFIA_Gabriel, post:311, topic:1109”]
haven’t said much significant.
[/quote]

But let’s go through your posts one by one:
The first one was the usual “I haven’t killed Rika” post, which pretty much everyone of us was doing more or less when all of this started. Posts 2 and 3 are basically some banter that didn’t really bring much to the table. I guess one could count your fourth post as putting Leo on the spot, but let’s look further. In your fifth post you questioned if our decision for No Death was really the best choice, and that’s definitely one post I see as being contributing. Your sixth post is basically a silly joke. Your seventh post is you both saying that you didn’t have much to say and that Kinzo should make good decisions, something that at that point Alice, despite being on the witch team, already said. Your 8th post is you saying what you did during the night, which you put as “brief research, and after that, being asleep”, so I guess you might have an ability we know nothing about yet, although it could also just mean “I looked through the posts up until now”. Your ninth post is you saying that you enjoy Kinzo’s and Leo’s argument coupled with what I guess are some nods to Higanbana. Your tenth post is restating what everyone who voted for Suzumu already said at that point, that it’s unlikely he’ll live and the implications of both him being human or not. Your 11th post is misunderstanding Black Battler’s statement (if we assume him being human of course). And your 12th post is asking Leo if he has any leads and also some harmless banter with Kinzo about his English Breakfast. Well, and your 13th is you asking me why you are on my list and Black Battler isn’t.

Now, for the night, if we have a human side protector of some sort, I would say this person should ask themselves which role is most important to keep: The Tracker, the guy who definitely kills people and says he’ll die soon anyway, or the Detective.

Furthermore, the fact that the witches most likely didn’t kill again last night is something that makes me very wary as well. As it stands, purposefully deciding to not kill, regardless which side decides that, is always seen as a suboptimal strategy, which honestly makes me question my own assessment of Kinzo. What I’m saying is that we might have a witch that is immune to investigative abilities. Ultimately, if Kinzo has been lying can be assessed after the next night, so I would wait until then for doubting him. Right now, I still trust him being human.

What if the witches don’t have a kill ability until I die?

Just an idea that popped into my head.

I honestly had a similar idea, namely that the witches don’t have a kill ability period, but instead have very defensive abilities. If that’s actually the case, then this is definitely a very unconventional game. But like I said, I’ll trust you until you either die or live longer than you yourself said you could (taking the day longer because you might have been protected into account).

Hmm… I wonder if Keiichi, as the Unaligned Neutral, was the only non-human with a kill ability and that every time he would kill, we would make it the witches fault?

Just an idea that sprung into my head.

If the witches really don’t have any kill-ability then I feel sorry for the them since they need to get down to one human in order to win. Feel like it would tip the scales a bit too much to the human side.

@MAFIA_Higanbana @MAFIA_Shion @MAFIA_Black_Battler @MAFIA_Kinzo @MAFIA_Suzumu @MAFIA_Rose @MAFIA_Kanon @MAFIA_Gabriel @MAFIA_Lucia @MAFIA_Alice @MAFIA_Mion @MAFIA_Leo @MAFIA_Keiichi

Nobody got much sleep that night. Everyone was worried about what could possibly happen. Ultimately there was nothing to do but to wait and hope for the best possible outcome.

At 6 o’ clock, people started coming into the parlor. As more and more of them gathered, something felt strange. Two people who’d generally been pretty on point with their timing so far were suddenly not showing up. Could it be…?

Moving faster than last time, they quickly set out to search for the two of them. And there they were, lying face down in a pool of blood in a hallway.

@MAFIA_Leo is dead. He was Human Aligned, played by Restkastel.

@MAFIA_Higanbana is dead. She was Witch Aligned, played by MrDent.

But the nightmare was not over yet… it was time for the curtain to rise on the fourth day.


You have 48 hours to vote for someone. Halftime will take place in roughly 24 hours, at which point Majority Lockdowns will also become possible.

Well, @MAFIA_Kinzo is supposedly on borrowed time right now. Which of these two did you shoot. I assume Higanbana, since Leo was helping out, but I need to ask anyway.

1 Like

Higanbana. Duh.

Hey, just covering the pleasantries, old man. No need for the blunt rudeness. Act your age.

1 Like