I refuse. Of course it’s in the auditorium, that was never meant to confuse, I even hinted to it in my previous response.
The culprits were Aimee, Arvin, Mark, and Jamie. After everyone went to their rooms, Aimee went to the balcony of the auditorium from outside the building . She may have used a rope of some sort to create a ladder of sorts to enter and exit the balcony. After killing Shuta, she left the auditorium. Aimee later opened the door as a ruse to “discover the body”. Afterwards, Aimee killed Garovel and Medlin and played dead herself, Mark, Arvin, and Jamie knew Aimee was playing dead so of course they weren’t fooled. Afterwards, sometime before 8:00 A.M., Mark, Aimee, Arvin, and/or Jamie managed to kill Madinson. Possible way they could have done this was : They never actually woke up Madinson, they killed her, placed her in the lecture room and locked it from the outside. The narration states they simply grabbed the master key, not that the master key was with Madinson’s body! They did this to create an illusion of a closed room to throw off the police
[/quote]
Nothing was used to scale down the balcony.
The culprits were Aimee, Arvin, Mark, and Jamie. After everyone went to their rooms,but before Shuta went to the auditorium, Aimee went to the balcony of the auditorium from the auditorium side and hid there. She expected Shuta to show up there for some reason . After killing Shuta, she opened the auditorium door as part of ruse to “discover the body”. Afterwards, Aimee killed Garovel and Medlin and played dead herself, Mark, Arvin, and Jamie knew Aimee was playing dead so of course they weren’t fooled. Afterwards, sometime before 8:00 A.M., Mark, Aimee, Arvin, and/or Jamie managed to kill Madinson. Possible way they could have done this was : They never actually woke up Madinson, they killed her, placed her in the lecture room and locked it from the outside. The narration states they simply grabbed the master key, not that the master key was with Madinson’s body! They did this to create an illusion of a closed room to throw off the police
Really trying to get that one to stick, are you?
Nothing was used to scale up the balcony.
I think you mistunderstood my blue truth. I mean before Shuta opened the auditorium door himself as per the red truth, Aimee hid in the balcony (by going through the auditorium door, closing it, and hiding there)
How did she get up there?
There is no path in the auditorium to get to the balcony, and vice versa.
From the auditorium. She simply entered through the auditorium door “after everyone went to their rooms”, but before “Shuta entered the auditorium”. I thought it was established the balcony was in the auditorium?
Allright time to the equivalent of my small bomb theory for this gameboard :
The culprits were Aimee, Arvin, Mark, and Jamie. After everyone went to their rooms, Aimee entered the basement of the Swiss building, or at least some sort of floor beneath the auditorium. . She entered a room that was beneath the auditorium, and either through the floorboard or through a vent, she stabbed Shuta from underneath… After killing Shuta, Aimee later opened the door to the auditorium as a ruse to “discover the body”. Afterwards, Aimee killed Garovel and Medlin and played dead herself, Mark, Arvin, and Jamie knew Aimee was playing dead so of course they weren’t fooled. Afterwards, sometime before 8:00 A.M., Mark, Aimee, Arvin, and/or Jamie managed to kill Madinson. Possible way they could have done this was : They never actually woke up Madinson, they killed her, placed her in the lecture room and locked it from the outside. The narration states they simply grabbed the master key, not that the master key was with Madinson’s body! They did this to create an illusion of a closed room to throw off the police
1 Like
There is no underground room, or floor. In fact, the only rooms and floors accessible are the ones shown in the floor plans.
I’m surprised that this is still going. Time I start digging
After Shuta closed the door he was killed trhough the door, in other words, while the door was closed the culprit attacked him, probably with a gun. After he was dead Aimee opened the door and did the staging with the blade and everything else, and screamed to draw everyone there. Aimee could even be the killer herself. Between the first and the second days, Aimee killed Garovel and Meldin and pretended to be dead. The person who checked her body first could have been an accomplice and, wanting to achieve their goal alone, killed her before anyone noticed anything. Before 8:00 am of the third day the remaining culprit forced open the door to the lecture room and killed Madison. The same person made it look like the lecture room was closed at 8:00 am when it wasn’t.
Repeat these, please:
- The culprit was in the auditorium when Shuta was killed.
- At 8:00 am of the third day, the lecture room was completely sealed, meaning all doors, windows and any other means of entering or leaving the room couldn’t have been used without being broken down or unlocked.
The culprit was in the auditorium when Shuta was killed.
At 8:00 am of the third day, the lecture room was completely sealed, meaning all doors, windows and any other means of entering or leaving the room couldn’t have been used without being broken down or unlocked.
Can you repeat “Shuta died before Aimee opened the auditorium door on August 13th”?
Shuta died before Aimee opened the auditorium door on August 13th after roll call.
Let’s see if I can poke some holes. This is a single theory I got from analysing your red. I’ll make a paragraph for each murder. I’ll highlight a few reds, but they were copypasted so there’s nothing new.
The auditorium was locked after Shuta entered it. When Shuta closed the door, only Shuta was in the room. Shuta was in perfect health when he closed the door. The culprit was in the auditorium when Shuta was killed. Shuta died before Aimee opened the auditorium door on August 13th after roll call. When Aimee arrived in the auditorium Shuta was dead. The auditorium door was not opened after Shuta entered it until Aimee found his body. Therefore, Aimee could have opened the door to the auditorium before the roll call and found Shuta’s body before he got killed, after that she left and Shuta ended up being killed by someone, and after the roll call he was once again found by Aimee, now dead. The culprit could be anyone, even Aimee considering she arrived in the auditorium when he was alive and after he was dead. She could even have killed him when she entered the first time.
Everyone was killed where their bodies were found. None of them would be fooled by someone playing dead. Following the possibility Aimee killed Shuta, she’s most likely the one who killed Garovel and Meldin and pretended to be dead. Someone amongst Mark, Jamie and Arvin knew about that, and the first to check her body was the one who knew that, that person killed her before any of the others could have noticed she was alive, thus creating the illusion all three of them were dead in the first place.
After Madison locked the lecture room, she never opened it. The key Madison acquired after being roused was the master key. Madison locked the lecture room. At 8:00 am of the third day, the lecture room was completely sealed, meaning all doors, windows and any other means of entering or leaving the room couldn’t have been used without being broken down or unlocked. Madison was killed after locking herself in the lecture room. This means the one who killed Aimee wasn’t finished with his plan and decided to kill Madison on the following day. Before 8:00 am he opened the lecture room and killed Madison. At 8:00 am he pretended to break down the lecture room and created the illusion it was locked. However this is only necessary if it’s asumed the others thought the door was locked, after all, the story only mentions they checked on her, never specifying the condition of the door.
1 Like
Aimee only opened the door to the Auditorium once that day.
That’s not enough!!
The auditorium was locked after Shuta entered it. When Shuta closed the door, only Shuta was in the room. Shuta was in perfect health when he closed the door. The culprit was in the auditorium when Shuta was killed. Shuta died before Aimee opened the auditorium door on August 13th after roll call. When Aimee arrived in the auditorium Shuta was dead. The auditorium door was not opened after Shuta entered it until Aimee found his body. Aimee only opened the door to the Auditorium once that day. Therefore, Aimee could have opened the door to the auditorium after the roll call and found Shuta’s body alive, her accomplice, who could be Arvin, Mark, or Jamie, then entered in the auditorium and killed Shuta. When Aimee arrived in the auditorium, Shuta was already dead, so she screamed to lure everyone there.
Everyone was killed where their bodies were found. None of them would be fooled by someone playing dead. Following that reasoning, Aimee is the one who killed Garovel and Meldin and pretended to be dead. Someone amongst Mark, Jamie and Arvin knew about that, and the first to check her body was the one who knew that, that person killed her before any of the others could have noticed she was alive, thus creating the illusion all three of them were dead in the first place.
After Madison locked the lecture room, she never opened it. The key Madison acquired after being roused was the master key. Madison locked the lecture room. At 8:00 am of the third day, the lecture room was completely sealed, meaning all doors, windows and any other means of entering or leaving the room couldn’t have been used without being broken down or unlocked. Madison was killed after locking herself in the lecture room. This means the one who killed Aimee wasn’t finished with his plan and decided to kill Madison on the following day. Before 8:00 am he opened the lecture room and killed Madison. At 8:00 am he pretended to break down the lecture room and created the illusion it was locked. However this is only necessary if it’s asumed the others thought the door was locked, after all, the story only mentions they checked on her, never specifying the condition of the door.
Contradicts one of the red.
A ghost pitifully reduced to minor details.
The auditorium was locked after Shuta entered it. When Shuta closed the door, only Shuta was in the room. Shuta was in perfect health when he closed the door. The culprit was in the auditorium when Shuta was killed. Shuta died before Aimee opened the auditorium door on August 13th after roll call. When Aimee arrived in the auditorium Shuta was dead. The auditorium door was not opened after Shuta entered it until Aimee found his body. Aimee only opened the door to the Auditorium once that day. Therefore, Aimee’s accomplice, who could have been Arvin, Mark, or Jamie, could have opened the door to the auditorium, which made Aimee find Shuta’s body, the accomplice then entered in the auditorium and killed Shuta. When Aimee arrived in the auditorium, Shuta was already dead, so she screamed to lure everyone there.
Everyone was killed where their bodies were found. None of them would be fooled by someone playing dead. Following that reasoning, Aimee is the one who killed Garovel and Meldin and pretended to be dead. Someone amongst Mark, Jamie and Arvin knew about that, and the first to check her body was the one who knew that, that person killed her before any of the others could have noticed she was alive, thus creating the illusion all three of them were dead in the first place.
After Madison locked the lecture room, she never opened it. The key Madison acquired after being roused was the master key. Madison locked the lecture room. At 8:00 am of the third day, the lecture room was completely sealed, meaning all doors, windows and any other means of entering or leaving the room couldn’t have been used without being broken down or unlocked. Madison was killed after locking herself in the lecture room. This means the one who killed Aimee wasn’t finished with his plan and decided to kill Madison on the following day. Before 8:00 am he opened the lecture room and killed Madison. At 8:00 am he pretended to break down the lecture room and created the illusion it was locked. However this is only necessary if it’s asumed the others thought the door was locked, after all, the story only mentions they checked on her, never specifying the condition of the door.
Aimee found Shuta’s body for the first time when she opened the door.