Devil's Playground - Game 3

I refer you to this.

The living group enters in the guest mansion. Astrid locks Arya and Adolin in the basement. Astrid and Shallan head to the first floor. Shallan then leaves the first floor, she doesn’t have to open any entrance, she used an entrance that was either unlocked or had been left open. Shallan finds Dalinar and kills him. Dalinar either entered in the mansion while the living group was entering it, or was outside the mansion and was spotted by Shallan, she wasn’t on the first floor when this happened. Astrid also left the first floor like Shallan, and headed to the basement, she opens the basement window, which was unlocked by Arya or Adolin after they were locked in the basement. Inside the basement, Astrid locks the window, kills Arya and Adolin, and breaks down the window to leave the basement.

Neither Arya nor Adolin unlocked the basement window,

While the living group is entering in the guest mansion, Dalinar enters through the basement window and leaves it unlocked. Astrid locks Arya and Adolin in the basement. Astrid and Shallan head to the first floor. Shallan then leaves the first floor, she doesn’t have to open any entrance, she used an entrance that was either unlocked or had been left open. Shallan finds Dalinar and kills him, she wasn’t on the first floor when this happened. Astrid also left the first floor like Shallan, and headed to the basement, she opens the basement window, which was unlocked by Dalinar. Inside the basement, Astrid locks the window, kills Arya and Adolin, and breaks down the window to leave the basement.


Regarding All entrances into the basement were locked at the time the door was locked. Which door? When?

I refer you to these Reds.

Where was he killed?

All entrances into the basement were locked at the time the door to the Basement was locked by Astrid.

The living group enters in the mansion. Astrid locks Arya and Adolin in the basement. Astrid and Shallan head to the first floor. Shallan then leaves the first floor, she doesn’t have to open any entrance, she used an entrance that was either unlocked or had been left open. Shallan finds Dalinar and kills him, she wasn’t on the first floor when this happened. Astrid also left the first floor like Shallan, and headed to the basement. Astrid breaks down the basement window, which was locked, kills Arya and Adolin and once again leaves through the window by breaking it down.

The Basement window was, without a doubt, opened between the times where the group arrives at the guest house and the bodies were found.

While the living group is entering in the guest mansion, Dalinar enters through the basement window and leaves using the door to the basement before Arya and Adolin arrive, at that time, the window was locked. Astrid locks Arya and Adolin in the basement. Astrid and Shallan head to the first floor. Shallan then leaves the first floor, she doesn’t have to open any entrance, she used an entrance that was either unlocked or had been left open. Shallan finds Dalinar and kills him, she wasn’t on the first floor when this happened. Astrid also left the first floor like Shallan, and headed to the basement. Astrid breaks down the basement window, which was locked, kills Arya and Adolin and once again leaves through the window by breaking it down.

1 Like

Arya and Adolin were the first ones to enter the Basement.

Repeat these:

  1. “The basement window was locked when Astrid locked the door to the basement”
  2. “When Astrid locked the door to the basement, only Arya and Adolin were inside the basement”
  3. “Astrid only locked the door to the basement once, and, at that time, Arya and Adolin were alive”

The basement window was locked when Astrid locked the door to the basement

When Astrid locked the door to the basement, only Arya and Adolin were inside the basement

Astrid only locked the door to the basement once, and, at that time, Arya and Adolin were alive

Define “empty” as “devoid of bodies”

’Empty’ means ‘devoid of bodies’.

While the group entered the mansion, Dalinar went to the basement window (by breaking it down)with a gun and sat on it (such that his legs are hanging towards the basement side of the window ledge). Arya and Adolin went to the basement. Astrid locked the basement door on them. Dalinar then shot Arya and Adolin. Astrid went to the basement door, unlocked it, and moved the bodies to outside the basement (ie; near the entrance). Shallan then came after Astrid and they both checked the bodies. Astrid notices Dalinar hanging from the window and shoots him. Then Astrid kills Shallan and then herself

The culprit’s whole body was in the basement when they killed Adolin and Arya.

Repeat this: “The basement window was locked when Astrid unlocked the door to the basement”

The basement window was locked when Astrid unlocked the door to the basement

While the group entered the mansion, Dalinar went to the basement window (by breaking it down)with a gun and sat on it (such that his legs are hanging towards the basement side of the window ledge). Arya and Shallan went to the basement. Astrid locked the basement door on them. Dalinar then entered the basement from the window shot them. Astrid went to the basement door, unlocked it, and moved the bodies to outside the basement (ie; near the entrance). She for some reason did notice Dalinar (ie: fatigue, stress) or Dalinar threatened to shoot her if she squealed on him. Dalinar then promptly made his escape to somewhere in the guest mansion. Shallan then came after Astrid and they both checked the bodies. On their way back either Shallan or Astrid saw Dalinar and killed him. Astrid then killed Shallan and then herself

The group enters in the guest mansion through the basement window. Astrid locks Arya and Adolin in the basement, and heads to the first floor with Shallan. Dalinar is found by Shallan while she wasn’t on the first floor, he entered in the guest mansion while the group was entering it, Shallan kills Dalinar. Astrid heads back to the basement breaking down the window, she kills Arya and Adolin and breaks down the window in order to leave the basement.