Mafia Under the Clear Sky(Game Over)

Gameboards
#121

I actually attempted something at the beginning of the day, sadly it failed gloriously. Guess I was still frustrated about that. But as to what led to that, Karifean:

Why did you decide to put that info out in the open right there? From where I’m standing, this was a bit too early to say that, as saying that basically made it impossible for the person to try to make Battler seem suspicious if Battler just so happened to message a Mafioso. I tried to salvage that by playing up the possibility of Battler lying, sadly I fooled the man himself as he said that he sent a message to Doldod right after that.

#122

I guessed that would be the case, just a way to get the game going again. Hope that’s OK.

Change vote: No Vote

#123

So that was your gambit, was it. I guess I should’ve held back on saying it. At the time I just wanted some information to start some even just slightly more informed reasoning.

#124

So at the beginning of this phase, you thought that Battler might have lied about his ability?

#125

The two I find most suspicious right now are Antra and Eternalmagician.
Now, Antra never posts terribly much in these, but he feels more passive than usual, really only replying when prompted.
Eternalmagician’s first post kind of just felt like a copy of the previous posts, which kinda looked like he’s just trying to blend in.
Then there’s the “Karifean voted against them on the first day”-factor. Now, I don’t know what alignment Karifean has, but I am convinced that, as mafia, he would try to slip one of his partners into his “random accusations to get things going”. I don’t think he could resist it. And if he’s town, that just naturally raises the likelihood of one of them being mafia. Another suspect eliminated and all that.

#126

Oh yeah, I’ve haven’t been feeling it lately, playing these games. To be honest, I’ve kinda regretted jumping into this game so fast, only to realize that I’ve been looking in every direction but this game. Don’t be surprised if I don’t join the next game.

#127

Nah, I didn’t. Battler passed up on such a good “ha was just fooling/baiting you guys” opportunity on Day 1, and yet he still insisted on having that ability. Also picto never puts up elaborate scum bait when he’s Mafia. I did think he might’ve been roleblocked though and I didn’t want to have to wait up to an entire online cycle just to see what actually happened.

Haha, just because I did that when the two of us were a Mafia team… xD

#128

Ummm, I really don’t have much of an idea about who is mafia or not. I just think Kari is a bit suspicious this game too though… When I compare his behavior to previous games, I find it closer to the games he was a mafia rather than a town.

The next people I suspect are Vyse and Blackrune. Blackrune could very well be using the tactic he mentioned and blame Kari… As for Vyse, well… It is mostly my gut. :stuck_out_tongue:

#129

Well that makes me torn. On one hand it sounds believable.
On the other hand, it sounds even more believable if you got mafia, since that tends to be more stressful and like something you might regret getting after the game started.
Gotta leave this vote here unless someone else convinces me of something better.

Vote: Antra

@Wonderlander: Now I’d kinda love that to be true just because using the same tactic I pointed out always sounds like fun mindgames~.
Also, your gut feeling on Vyse was off last time, so you’ll need a bit more to convince me there. :stuck_out_tongue:

Well, leaving me aside, I do think it’s very much possible one of those two is mafia, but probably not both. Unless they’re being really elaborate with their acting. If that many of the most active players are mafia we’re probably screwed.

#130

Oh, believe me, I probably would have been more invested if I were Mafia/Witch. Stressful or not, at least I wouldn’t feel so indifferent. Oh well.

#131

Huh, you think so? I’d love to alleviate your concerns but there’s not much I can say to that, it’s not something I actually pick up on myself. Maybe the games I played inbetween this and Mafia Roulette I (man that was a while ago already) changed my meta or something. shrug

#132

Man, I feel a bit left behind, because you all are used to each other and no how each other act in these games.
Now, are the mafia members trying to stay quiet or are they conversing a bit more than the others? Who could say for sure.
In any case, if Eternalmagician is trying to blend in as Blackrune mentioned, I think I might throw a vote that way. At least for now.
Vote: Eternalmagician

#133

We should probably reach a consensus very soon, as the phase ends in 3 hours give or take a few minutes. Looking through the last posts, it seems that the following is a more promising choice:

Change Vote: Antra

#134

I agree, in best case scenario we hit a Mafia and in worst case we hit someone who admit to not being that much into the game.

Change Vote: Antra

Or do anyone have any other ideas?

#135

You jumped on the “Lynch Antra” train really quickly. Maybe I should do this instead?

Change Vote: EternalMagician

#136

Antra: Blackrune, VyseGolbez, EternalMagician
EternalMagician: Honeycomb, Doldod

With 9 alive, it takes 5 to lynch.

I’m willing to give you folks a couple extra hours since I have some errands to run today. I recommend you make the best of them. Have an answer by, say, 5 PM EST though.

#137

@Wonderlander @Antra @Karifean @MAFIA_Battler You heard the lady. Pick one of the two or convince everyone to lynch someone else entirely if you don’t want a die to decide today’s lynch.

#138

My suspicions lean towards Antra logically, but I don’t want to kill someone before they can see how beautiful this game will surely be.

Hard choice…

#139

Antra is obviously going to vote for Eternal Magician so… It is up to us three to decide today’s lynch? I am more partial to Antra but… @Karifean? Any thoughts?

#140

I’m kinda not a fan of the whole dying thing so…

Vote: EternalMagician