The rules specify that the witches decide on a human to kill so I don’t feel the need to state it in the writeup. But just to make it clear: Antra was very much human.
Yeah, wow. Didn’t expect that… If anyone feel that they want to vote for me for that just to check if I’m a witch them go ahead, feel like I deserve it.
ok so Antra was human and he voted @EternalMagician alongside @UsagiTenpura and @Wonderlander. This honestly makes me believe that they are human. At the very least, @Wonderlander. Now, anyone who voted for @lobotomyprince is more of a suspect and now, we don’t have the luxury to screw up on a vote. @Doldod was the other person suspected alongside me and @EternalMagician. Of course I saw other suspect both @King_Titanite_XV and @midsummer.
But to be frank, I’m probably the most suspicious, which makes me prime target alongside @EternalMagician, @Doldod and @midsummer
We should look at the logs of the 4 of us, though anyone else’s logs are good as well if its something damming
1 Like
I am tempted to take you up on the offer. Now that lobotomyprince flipped human, you’re quite high on my suspect list.
Speaking of lobotomyprince, damn. Still, it’s not entirely unexpected that we wouldn’t hit on a witch on our first stab at the four Wonderlandervoters. I can only hope we will not repeat this mistake.
The witches killed Antra to resolve the inactivity situation…? I guess Antra wasn’t under much fire, and he was one of those who voted akafa, so nightkilling him is still to their advantage. After all, it keeps the most suspicious group as large as possible, decreasing the odds of hitting a witch.
At least it’s reassuring to know that if I ever get too busy and want to leave the game, the witch side has my back.
y tho. Have I done anything strange, other than post 20% less than before?
If I had to vote off anyone it would be Eternal but seriously pliskin, why me?
I could have totally killed off a human with the 2 way split and not received ANY suspicion whatsoever. You’d have to be a madman to think “well, what if there was a 2 way split of a human and a witch and the witch team got their witch buddy to vote off the human, only last second they realised someone would think of that so they purposely took out one of their own”
Like, wat.
Um. Well, quite frankly I’ve been meaning to ask this since I read yesterday’s backlog, basically uh…
@EternalMagician You said earlier yesterday that you thought doldod was your primary suspect. Was finding a small inconsistency among a 900+ replies thread over the span of 2 weeks really powerful enough to overturn your primary suspicion? Especially considering that your primary suspect was the first to vote against them? I mean I don’t even blame anyone for voting against lobotomy, they were pretty high on my list of suspicious people after you. But you yourself voiced earlier you thought they were genuinely trying to help (along pliskin) and then did a 180 flip from doldod to lobotomy after finding that small inconsistency. So I guess I’m… trying to ask what’s going on there.
In any case my reason for voting against you yesterday vanished now that we have information about you (ironically…). Well I’m pretty tempted to still vote for you tbh, but I don’t think we can afford to make hasty decisions right now, so at the very least I’m going to assume that ~2 days is enough for you to answer that question. Because quite frankly to me it does sorta look like a witch suicide trying to take out one last human before being obviously lynched and your first message of today… I dunno how to read it tbh, but I’m having a hard time thinking you’d be saying anything different if you were human or witch after what happened.
But in case you’re a human, asking us to kill you just to check if you’re one this late in the game is not the best strategy. Unless you want to cost us two mislynchs. Tho it’d have been a good one last turn or the one before.
I really don’t know what to make out of this heh. It’s like the “dumb mistake” idea has been used as excuses far too often in this game and I’m starting to think I may make a decision based on not wanting to risk losing to a witch using that excuse at this point.
Sorry, I guess I’m tired from work and a bit salt that everyone listened to your… idea thing. It’s better that I write my thoughts again when I’ll be less exhausted.
To be honest, I would do that. So I guess I am a madman
Vote:King_Titanite_XV
You mean…
2 Likes
Ok, sure.
Vote: SleepingPliskin
I based my suspicion on Doldod mostly on the four that was suspicious at the time, SleepingPliskin, Doldod, lobotomyprince and me, and that of the three other players Doldod was the one who was the most quiet and so would affect the game the least if it was wrong. Plus that I had some memories of Doldod being under suspicion before, though I could have been wrong about that.
So when I found something off like that I thought it could be a good way to catch a witch, especially in vanilla when we have so little information. Though sadly I was wrong and we lynched a human instead.
So it really was a dumb mistake. I though I saw an opening, took it and we paid for it, sadly.
Hmm. Fair enough.
I mean…
… was essentially the reason I voted for you.
Hmm. Well I don’t know what to think.
I may as well say it pretty straight tho.
I was unnerved by the fact that even tho you pointed out doldod as your primary suspect, you ultimately voted elsewhere, alongside him. Because saying “someone is suspicious” but then voting elsewhere is easy enough (remember how that kind of thought ended up ruining a certain game…). so I was under the impression that a possible witch team was you and doldod, afterall.
I mean, I still can’t rule it out, but it’s a possibility among so many that I don’t have a particularly strong incline toward it.
I also said on early day4 that the main scenario in which I could see muski being a witch making sense with his behaviour of that day is to “protect lobotomy or eternalmagician” and well, now that is down to you alone, eternalmagician.
But that doesn’t mean much, there’s just so many possibilities, I can only deny a few (such as finding it pretty unlikely that you and midsummer are both witches due to voting for each other. Same for you and wonderlander being both witches) and even so there’s nothing absolute there… odd things can happen.
I mean from my pov there’s 42 possible pairing of witches (at the base) and no matter how many pairing I deny, I can’t really drop this down to really low odds where a certain “couple” emerge as very likely over all others.
I guess I’m generally inclined to think witches have voted for lobotomy wether or not you are human simply because that’s where the axe fell tho and I’m at least strongly inclined to think wonderlander is human. Still, I feel like that line of reasoning is making me forget about muski’s existence and that seems a bit convenient, so I suppose I should say at least one witch.
1 Like
Bah
his behaviour of the previous day (day3)
… wait 42 is off.
21 possibilities (trying to map them out and now realizing it heh)
Guess brain fails at times.
3 Likes
You can take everything with me in it out. Trust me <3 That makes 15 already!
And am I the only one bored of this mafia game? Can we impose a time limit on ourselves because we barely use the 48 hours and I sure could use this ending sooner. And there are so many people waiting for a new mafia game. We shouldn’t disappoint.
So let’s go back to wonderlandervoters. EM, Doldod, and Pliskin. And I visited random.org and it said Doldod. So:
Vote: Doldod
I just want it to end.
Vote: Wonderlander
I don’t have a problem with hastening things up if people want to. It doesn’t seem like we make much use of the time we have in the first place.
Might as well continue with where I left off before before lobotomyprince caught my attention over the rest of the Wondervoters. @EternalMagician, you are too suspicious. You’ve been mostly passive with the exception of voting in favor of lynching humans. Today, your angle seems to be “oh yeah, totally kill me if you want to, I’ve screwed up too much so I deserve it”, which feels like a witch side sympathy play. And then there’s the whole thing Usagi mentioned about how you switched from Doldod to lobotomyprince a bit too fast.
Unless something comes up which might make me change my mind, this is what I will be going with for now.
Vote: EternalMagician
Wtf is this. Are we heading toward something even more lame than day3?