I love the Worst Idea Ever and I think we should do it.
The number of people really is putting us at a disadvantage.
I said I would switch my vote and I will. So unless he shows up this is where I’m sticking.
Vote: Muski
Kari, can I ask for a vote count?
We are entering the last 24 hours… I think we should start deciding who is the most suspicious. Can anybody do a vote tally BTW? Hard to do on phone.
And I am bad at explaining myself with words in games like these, but I will try my best right now.
I don’t think we should lynch Muski first. Lynching inactive players gives us the least amount of information. Plus, that takes a chance of somebody else entering in their place to the game. Lynching somebody active or semi-active and reading the reactions will be much more helpful.
And yes, in order to learn the maximum amount of information, we do have to lynch today. The people I am most suspicious of are as follows:
King
Rabla
Doldod
Vyse
Though they aren’t that major suspicions, they are more than the other people. Based on their actions and my reading of them.
So in spirit of sparking a discussion, lemme start the last 24 hours of suspicion, accusal and voting…
Vote: Rabla
Is it this time already?! I’d rather not shoot aimlessly, so even though I would like to retaliate (cough thesorceress cough) I’m not going to point any fingers.
NO VOTE
Sure thing. Since we’re at about halftime I was gonna do a rundown anyways.
Muski - 2 (King_Titanite_XV, thesorceress)
AMF - 1 (VyseGolbez)
Rabla - 1 (Wonderlander)
Antra - 1 (midsummer)
Rabla’s death could be informative. If he were to flip witch, that would make akafa, King and AMF’s decision to not join Antra in voting Rabla after they were so eager to join him in voting Blackrune quite suspicious. If he flips human… I guess that sucks, but no more than the death of any other human. I recommend focusing lynches on more inactive players early on, and Rabla hasn’t been too active so far, though in his defense, he did join in later than most.
Still, let’s entertain this possibility for a while.
Vote change: Rabla
Rabla, how attached are you to that head of yours? Any particular reasons why you might want to continue living past this day?
If I were a witch, I would probably be trying to make other humans suspicious of each other, not suspicious of myself by staying silent (or sleeping), gah!
Vote : SleepingPliskin
Why aren’t you?
I dunno, I don’t think that’s a very fair question so I’d like you to show us an examplary answer.
Because I been trying my best to stay active and promote conversation.
Also, Welcome to the gameboard, @Muski. It’s nice that everyone has finally spoken.
On one hand I don’t want to die, but you’ve managed to actually present a reason to do it which no-one else has done for anything.
I am unfortunately very human, so I would like to avoid this fate either way. It would be nice to survive long enough to participate with actual information.
Thanks for joining us.
Now that everyone’s on the board I’ll change my vote to the person I am actually finding the most suspicious at this point in time.
Change vote: akafa
I really don’t want to take you out, hon, but you’re not acting like yourself. I’ve only played games where you were human before and, in those games, you were talkative and roll-playing and in this one you’ve just been…quiet. Plus I thought your Blackrune thing was rather shady. I could be wrong, but that’s where I’m at right now.
I know its not a fair question, but to be fair, they got voted to be lynched, so they’re in immediate threat. Idk how I would respond in the situation. Maybe give my reasons as to why another person(s) might be witches. Tell why my actions made sense in the context of the game. Idk
Hm, I get why you suspect me. I voted for Blackrune just like Antra suggested just to press everyone, but seems like he dropped that idea and went to sleep and I didn’t see him voting for Rabla (like I already said) so I didn’t follow with the vote.
Still I don’t really know what to say here, it’s good that Muski is finally here but nothing is really happening, I did try to give my thoughts and I’m quite bad at it hehe. There isn’t much to roleplay too because no roles this time, but I think I would have been more active if there were tho!
So, I guess we are all voting for who we find suspicious? Alright, let me throw my hat in the bin.
Vote: King_Titanite_XV
I find the fact that he was the first one to join the Blackrune train to be rather shady, and I also find the fact that he voted for a inactive player that would yield the least amount of information without even waiting a full 24 hours to just be too easy.
Since people started voting, I’ll go with AMF for now because as he said he really wanted to lynch someone early and I think he is a little suspicious.
Vote: AMF
Okay so it looks like semi-productive conversation started while I was asleep. That’s good.
I’m not a witch because if I were a witch I wouldn’t be dumb enough to change my “No vote” (which I’m assuming was read as “No lynch”) to “Unvote” just after everyone started semi-accepting it. I’m eager to lynch someone because the only way humans get 100% trustworthy information in this vanilla game is when people die. If we just let people die at night without going after anyone, then whatever information we get will more than likely be in favor of the witches. We’re kind of too big of a mess right now for them to start working out complicated wheels-within-wheels tactics, after all.
Well good point, but I jumped on the first train because one vote barely gets anyone talking - I think it was one of the Roulette Games that demonstrated this? I’m not sure…
Anyway, as for the second one, no-one else had brought it up! Of course I’m going to point it out before going off for like a buncha hours!
Dammit antra these seem really obvious as reasons, you’re making me suspect you…
I’m pretty convinced Muski is a human because as a witch they would’ve been told to NOT go No Vote and stand out like a sore thumb. And for now while I agree that akafa123 is being…different…this game I will chalk that up to no roles being present. So, sorry Antra, but I might push my vote towards you soon.
Also @Muski you say NO VOTE in bold. This is your default state. There’s no need to bold this?
Or perhaps you meant to do No Death or No Lynch?
Also I want to bring up midsummer’s idea of lynching whoever gives us the most information as to everyone else’s moves. He said Rabla and gave some reasons for that but thesorceress, myself and Pliskin could also be contenders for that.
I’m in agreement as to this idea but I’m not sure who would give us a lot of info tbh…
I get what you’re saying but we should have at least talked and not jump at the lynching. We can give pressure through collaborative interrogation. If you are really human, then help us by giving us a detailed description of your perspective
Yeah I agree with you there. I put myself in risk because I’m talking too much. However, I prefer to get conversations going to get some information with each individual
Alright, though I don’t know how trustworthy speculation is. I feel like some of the people posting their thoughts are just skilled witches who are good at gaining people’s favor.
People I find suspicious:
Rabla. Doesn’t seem to want to talk much, and avoided my question about whether they found anyone suspicious.
Pliskin. Sorry, but you seem too relaxed and trustworthy while the rest of us are in at least a bit of a fuss. Well, that might just be a personality trait though (this is the bad part about not knowing anyone).
midsummer. This one is honestly just complete gut instinct. I’m sorry.
I retract my suspicions about Vyse because I think they’re being pretty reasonable considering that they’re busy right now.
Not suspicious:
Usagi. They haven’t really made any slip-ups or said anything odd despite consistently sending rather long responses.
thesorceress. Hasn’t gone in any unreasonable directions and seems to just be a pretty mild human player.
I have no opinion on anyone else, but I still marginally distrust even people I didn’t list. After all, we don’t have much to go off of right now and I don’t think I’m enough of a people-person to be able to get really accurate reads.