They could have alternatively been aiming to hit an unremarkable target to guarantee not clashing with the protector.
It’s not a bad first day tactic.
Hmm. Interesting. I keep forgetting this game isn’t totally vanilla.
Picto, why the lack of roleplay in that last post? Did you just forget?
“Quiet down you.”
Ah, okay! Sorry, I was just wondering if it meant something.
Ahahahaha… whatever.
Because of the lack of roleplay, I almost missed the important thing about this post. Picto says “they”, which means Picto hit Wonderlander, and the witch team hit Plsikin.
WELP NOW WE KNOW USAGI ISN’T A WITCH LOL
Maybe we already figured that out from the Final Fantasy stuff? I don’t know, man. That stuff has me super confused.
Okay. I read through the thread again, looking for why Pliskin would’ve been hit. And honestly, what I got from this readthrough is that we should be less trusting of Pictoshark.
For one thing, Pliskin voted for Picto before switching to no lynch. For another, there’s no guarantee Picto isn’t on the witch team. I remember glancing at a previous game where someone with a kill ability was on a witch team; I think it was whoever roleplayed Higanbana? Picto also didn’t vote again after his vote for Kari was invalidated. But from the sound of it, he wasn’t a fan of my No Lynch Peace and Love train. He also wanted the protector to protect him in case he got hit by the witch team, but if he were a witch, that would’ve been a great play if the protector listened and essentially wasted their ability on protecting a witch, leaving them two free nightkills.
So, long story short, and because I don’t feel like typing more, @pictoshark, why aren’t you a witch?
1 Like
Oh wow, I’m honestly impressed.
Yeah the thing to question here is “if the witches are another party, wether or not picto is a third party or really on the side of humans, why would the witches want to kill someone who’s going after pictoshark”
And the other question is “who’s the obvious person who’s been protecting pictoshark”
There’s more, but I’ll let that be for now XD
Oh wow, Usagi impressed by me? I feel honored.
“Real response incoming.”
1 Like
I do have to say, before you post your response, that analysis was mildly fueled by the fact that you said I didn’t have the “mental capacity” to be helpful to you.
Hey anyone trying to reason things out are worthy players, wether they are right or wrong. It’s a game where we make bets based on the best of our abilities. Sometimes they’re right, sometimes they’re wrong.
And anyone who says this is bad should be de facto considered suspicious
1 Like
“I have a pretty good theory, too.”
Zep the Third nods.
"Consider the following…
"
3 Likes
Aren’t you the cat tho?
Wow, that takes me back to Bill Nye the Science Guy.
Please… consider the following!
I have to add that zepfur is awesome, but for reasons entirely unrelated to my comment about flare.
“C-Crap! I forgot!”
The cat gasps and puts his paws to his cheeks.
1 Like
“Before we begin I’d appreciate it if we were on the same page. Go skim Game IV, it seems from the present situation that this game has taken some setup ideas from it.”
For one thing, Pliskin voted for Picto before switching to no lynch. For another, there’s no guarantee Picto isn’t on the witch team.
“This is by far the most broken point in your reasoning. Yes he did. He then backed down from that vote, like you noted. In addition he did not make any points, he merely voted for me and then switched off of that. If the intent behind the strike was to hit people who spoke ill of myself then surely it’d be wiser to go after those who actually made points, right?”
Picto also didn’t vote again after his vote for Kari was invalidated. But from the sound of it, he wasn’t a fan of my No Lynch Peace and Love train.
“I intended to stay up until the deadline for the night phase and then fall asleep. However, I fell asleep before it came back up again. As for why I am sleeping outside of the usual hours for my timezone, @Aurora could attest to that along with backing up my claim were she allowed to post here. In short (as long as I am remembering things correctly) I was asleep for the duration of time between Kari being modkilled and the majority being reached.”
He also wanted the protector to protect him in case he got hit by the witch team, but if he were a witch, that would’ve been a great play if the protector listened and essentially wasted their ability on protecting a witch, leaving them two free nightkills.
“And equally if I were a human that move also makes perfect sense.”
@pictoshark, why aren’t you a witch?
"Hangh. Because I made it clear who I was killing, because I have been open with information, because I asked everyone to put forward who I ought to kill, because I knew who to side with during the Kari/thesorceress contradiction earlier in the game, because I didn’t take the easy shade I could throw on Flare and pointed out the counterargument he ought to have made instead, because killing abilities are not exclusive to the witch side…
Is that enough for you?"
“Hmm… Yeah, that all makes sense. You’ve pretty much overturned the accusation entirely.”
Vote: Pictoshark
“Oh you…!”